Roblightbody dot com
  • Home
    • What's New?
    • About Rob >
      • QE2 Talks & speaker
    • Contact
  • Rob's Blog
  • Gadgets
  • Ocean Liners
    • Queen Mary 2 >
      • QM2 News in service
      • QM2 News (When New)
      • QM2 News (Pre Float-out) >
        • My Travels
      • QM2 Reviews
      • QM2 A Ship of Superlative Comparisons
    • Queen Elizabeth 2 >
      • QE2 in Dubai (QE2 Today)
      • QE2 Forum (link)
      • My own QE2 Story >
        • My QE2 Photos
        • 2008 Stephen Payne QE2 Lecture
        • 2008 QE2 Last Thoughts
        • 2008 QE2 Clyde Farewell
        • 2008 August QE2 Cruise
        • 2007 December QE2 Cruise
        • 2007 September QE2 Clyde
        • 2005 August QE2 Queensferry
        • 2003 June QE2 Queensferry
        • 1987 QE2 April Bremerhaven >
          • QE2 April 1987 Exterior Photos
          • QE2 April 1987 Interior Photos
      • QE2 News >
        • QE2 Dubai News (2008 to 2015) >
          • Fears grow over bid to turn QE2 into a hotel in Dubai
        • QE2 News 2008
        • QE2 Sold to Dubai Articles (2007)
        • QE2 News 2007
        • QE2 News 2006
        • QE2 News 2002 to 2005
        • QE2 News 1998 to 2001
      • QE2's Name
      • QE2 1987 Rebirth
      • QE2 Reviews 1997 to 2007
      • Speed Queen
      • QE2 Storm Photos
      • QE2 1975 Guide
      • 1969 Shipshapes
      • QE2 Sydney 2006
      • QE2 Cutaways
      • QE2 in 1969
      • QE2 Fuel Economy
      • QE2 Facts
      • Bridgecam Snaps
      • QE2 1995 Freak Wave
      • QE2 Bridge View
    • SS France >
      • SS France Swan Song (2001)
      • 2006 Finalé >
        • Telegraph April 2006
        • Miami Herald
        • AP News May 2006
        • Justin Huggler Article
        • BBC News June 2006
        • July 2006 (MSNBC)
      • Scrapping Allowed (2007)
    • United States >
      • Maiden Voyage
      • NCL Buys SS United States
    • Queen Elizabeth
    • Queen Mary >
      • No rushing Churchill and his ship of state
      • RMS Queen Mary News >
        • 2007 Fate of rusting Queen Mary in the balance
        • 2006 Queen Marys Meet
        • 2004 As ship and work of art, the QM still an original
        • 2001 Is Queen Mary seaworthy?
        • 2000 Sir John Brown Dies
        • 1998 - Queen of Kitsch
    • Normandie
    • Lusitania & Mauritania
    • Aquitania >
      • Aquitania Emails
    • Other Liners >
      • Transvaal Castle
      • Saxonia
      • Ivernia
      • Caronia
  • Cars
    • Classic Mini >
      • My Classic Minis
      • History >
        • End of Mini >
          • FT Sep 2000
          • Glasgow Herald
          • BBC News
          • Autocar March 2000
        • Sexist Adverts
        • John Cooper Dies
      • Brochures
      • My Archive
      • The MPi Minis >
        • Official Launch Documents
        • Classic Mini Postcards
        • MPI Mini Colours and trim, 1997 onwards
        • 1998 - Examples of MPI changes from SPI
        • 1998 MPI Mini Price List
        • Extracts from the 1996 Brochure launching the 1997 model year Minis
      • SPI Mini ACR2 Fault Code Reader
    • First new MINI
    • Ford Puma
    • Mazda MX-5 Miata
    • Austin Princess
    • Favourite Cars
  • PS Waverley
  • Scotland
    • Jeely Piece Song
    • Flower of Scotland
    • Where's the Glasgow?
    • I Belong to Glasgow (link)
  • Chuckles
  • Cool Websites
Home > Ocean Liners > QE2 > Me & QE2 > My final thoughts on QE2 as she leaves service

My final thoughts on QE2, as she starts her final voyage.

When Cunard announced the sale of QE2 to Dubai, they announced it as a restoration, a preservation.  Loyal QE2 fans, of which there are very many indeed, were upset, but happy the ship was to be saved.

It has become clearer recently that her fate is to be rather different and I'm really quite annoyed by it.  All her lovely original cabins will be destroyed.  Her appearance will be destroyed by additional decks.  Her lovely funnel will be removed and replaced with a penthouse.  Her epic engines will be gone.  Cunard would not have got such an easy ride from the press if this had come out to start with, rather than dribbled out.

Many "liner buffs", myself included, would rather see the ship scuttled or scrapped.

Cunard is trying to steer the media by describing just how "past it" their 39 year old ship is and how she couldn't possibly go on but she could have, or could have been saved properly ...   
  • They jumped at the first offer they got.   
  • They didn't advertise the ship for sale, and didn't give people time to put bids together.   
  • The ship could have gone on for a long time with another big refit (like she had in 1987).  She could have been a famous classic historic liner - the fastest in the world - just imagine...
  • Her powerplant is still modern and efficient, and her hull is strong.  She could even have gone on for another few years without a major refit at all.
  • The Rotterdam was saved and sympathetically preserved while providing modern hotel and entertainment accommodation.  This could have been a model for QE2.  Have a look here - http://ssrotterdam.com/
  • The engines are not needed any more, but they're the first thing anyone interested in the ship would want to see.  Imagine standing next to one of the 9 engines - each bigger than a double-decker bus?
  • The Queen Mary in Long Beach suddenly looks like a text book preservation project, whereas before it looked like a cock-up.
  • Contrary to what some people may tell you, there was still *a lot* of original QE2 to save in 2008.

Anyway, I've not managed to keep up with all the last news releases and articles about QE2, because I don't have the energy and it upsets me.

My long QE2 story ended on October the 5th on the River Clyde along with many tens of thousands of people who came out to see the most beautiful ship they'd ever seen and wonder why it was going to a strange land to be chopped up.

Goodbye QE2... I will never forget you, but will never visit your remains in Dubai.  Thank you for the memories.

    - Rob Lightbody, 22nd October 2008
Picture

Sections

Rob's Blog
​Gadget Reviews

Ships

PS Waverley
Queen Mary 2
Queen Elizabeth 2
RMS Queen Elizabeth
RMS Queen Mary
More Liners

Cars

Classic Mini
New MINI (2001)
Mazda Miata MX-5
Wedge Princess
Ford Puma
Other Favourites

Everything Else

Whats New
About Rob
Contact Rob
Chuckles
Cool Sites